When Josh Siegel confided to one of his Berklee professors that he was dropping out to move home and start a band, that professor had one response: "don't procrastinate." A Craigslist ad went up immediately upon Siegel's return to Chicago: "Do you consider Radiohead to be soul music? Do you hear Muddy Waters in between the notes on the White Album?" Drummer Ren Mathew, newly liberated from a dissolving power-pop outfit, answered the ad. The two ambled through Dylan's "It's All Over Now Baby Blue," talked about their shared love of Bernard Purdie, and Bailiff was born.